UK EV Target Slashed, Louise Haigh Faces Climate and Industry Pressure
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Pemerintah Inggris bersiap memotong target penjualan kendaraan listrik (EV) 2030 dari 80% menjadi sekitar 60%, memicu perdebatan antara kepentingan industri otomotif dan komitmen dekarbonisasi.
- Menteri Senior Louise Haigh akan memfinalkan keputusan setelah rapat di Downing Street, sementara PM Andy Burnham menghindari konflik kepentingan karena istrinya duduk di dewan jaringan pengisian EV.
- Pelemahan mandat ini berpotensi merugikan sektor infrastruktur pengisian daya senilai ยฃ1,7 miliar dan mencoreng citra kepemimpinan iklim Inggris di mata investor serta anggota parlemen Partai Buruh.

The UK government is expected to significantly lower its electric vehicle (EV) sales target this week, a move that eases pressure on carmakers but raises concerns among Labour MPs and environmental activists. The decision is a test of the government's commitment to its green agenda amid a range of other controversial policies.
Senior Minister Louise Haigh, who de facto carries out the role of deputy prime minister, will set out the final plan after a crucial meeting at Downing Street on Wednesday. The meeting aims to resolve a long-running dispute between the transport, energy, and business departments. According to government sources, Haigh is likely to approve a cut to the EV sales target of about a quarter from the original provision, which initially required 80% of new car sales to be EVs by 2030.
The decision comes ahead of Prime Minister Andy Burnham's departure for his first COP summit, where he and Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband will promote electrification globally. However, a number of MPs are already disappointed by the approval of the Jackdaw gas field and cuts to green program funding to finance an increase in the defense budget. Now, decisions on the Rosebank oil field and the EV mandate are in the spotlight.
Labour MP Lizzi Collinge stressed that the decision on the ZEV (zero emission vehicle) mandate will have a major impact on the climate, perhaps the biggest on the prime minister's desk. "It will also determine the direction of handling the cost of living and help lower energy prices over the next decade," she said. Similarly, Catherine Fookes of Monmouthshire stressed the need to maintain the ZEV mandate and reject Rosebank.
A government spokesperson stated that the government remains united in its commitment to the ZEV mandate and that no final decision has been made. "We are committed to ending the sale of new cars that rely entirely on petrol and diesel by 2030, and to achieving 100% zero-emission new car and van sales by 2035, in line with the legally binding net zero target," the spokesperson said. The consultation on the mandate, the spokesperson claimed, will not change that commitment and will ensure a pragmatic and balanced approach.
Since the rules were introduced by the previous Conservative government, carmakers have been required to sell only EVs by 2035, with a gradual increase in the proportion to 80% by 2030. The policy is estimated to deliver the largest emissions reductions compared with other policies. However, carmakers have long warned that the interim targets are unrealistic due to high inflation and cost-of-living pressures. The Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) estimates the industry will fail to meet this year's 33% target, with battery EVs accounting for only 26.6% of new car sales in the first ten months.
"The gap between demand and the mandated target continues to widen. Meaningful change to the trajectory, together with expanded flexibility, is important to bridge that gap, protecting jobs and investment while keeping the UK's zero-emission transition on track," said Mike Hawes, CEO of SMMT.
The government has softened the target several times since the policy was first proposed. In August, it launched another review with five options: keeping the mandate unchanged; keeping 80% but extending flexibility through 2034; reducing the interim target to 70%; to 60%; or to 50%. The consultation triggered an internal battle in Whitehall. Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds pushed for the 2030 target to be as low as possible, namely 50%. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander is believed to want around 60%, while Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh and her predecessor Ed Miliband want to keep it at 80%.
The prime minister usually settles disputes, but Burnham avoided the decision because his wife, Marie-France van Heel, is a board adviser to the Manchester-based EV charging network Be.EV. Government sources expect Haigh to approve a 2030 target of around 60% while extending flexibility through 2034. However, she has reportedly told colleagues not to push again for a cut to the target in the future.
The decision will not only disappoint some Labour MPs but also environmental groups and the EV charging industry, which relies on high vehicle sales to recoup investment. Shane Brennan, CEO of the trade association ChargeUK, warned that weakening the mandate puts ยฃ1.7 billion of charging infrastructure at risk, along with related jobs and supply chains. "Investor confidence in charging will be shaken by the third change in three years. The government should not lose sight of the long-term implications of appearing to give in to the short-term interests of global car importers," he said.
Paul McNamee, director of the Labour Climate and Environment Forum, judged that a significant weakening of the 80% target would be seen as a setback for climate leadership. "If the government does this, they must provide assurances that the mandate will not be weakened again in the coming years, that the 2035 target for EVs remains in place, and that they present a strong industrial strategy to build a UK EV manufacturing base that protects jobs in the long term," he said.
For Indonesia, this UK policy can serve as a mirror of how developed countries grapple with the energy transition amid economic pressure. Indonesia itself is developing an EV ecosystem with ambitious targets, yet faces similar challenges: a gap between targets and actual sales, uneven charging infrastructure, and resistance from the conventional automotive industry. The UK's decision to soften the mandate could strengthen the argument that the EV transition requires a gradual approach that takes into account market readiness and people's purchasing power. However, if there is too much compromise, the investment signal for infrastructure developers and battery manufacturers could weaken.
Going forward, the question is whether the UK government will be able to maintain a balance between protecting the national automotive industry and meeting its legally binding climate commitments. Haigh's decision this week will be an indicator of how much weight climate considerations carry in economic policymaking under Burnham's leadership. If the target is cut without guarantees of long-term stability, the risk of losing investor confidence and slowing the decarbonization of the transport sector will become more real.



