UK MP Criticizes Corporate Ownership Transparency Plans in Guernsey and Jersey
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Sir Andrew Mitchell menilai proposal Guernsey dan Jersey tidak cukup jauh untuk membongkar pemilik manfaat akhir perusahaan.
- Pembatasan akses dan syarat administratif dinilai justru menyulitkan penyidik mengungkap kejahatan keuangan.
- Pemerintah kedua yurisdiksi membantah dan mengklaim tetap memenuhi standar internasional.

Westminster Member of Parliament Sir Andrew Mitchell has sharply criticized plans by Guernsey and Jersey to open access to corporate ownership information for certain applicants. According to him, the policy will not be effective enough in combating money laundering and terrorist financing because it still leaves a major gap for investigators.
Guernsey and Jersey previously announced proposals that would allow journalists, academics, and other parties with a legitimate interest to apply for access to a company's beneficial owner data. Until now, that information has been available only to law enforcement, regulators, and certain institutions carrying out anti-money laundering due diligence. The plan is part of a joint commitment by the three jurisdictions—including the Isle of Man—in December 2023 to strengthen transparency.
However, Mitchell, who has long called for strict scrutiny of corporate ownership, sees strong indications that the proposal will fail to meet expectations. He highlighted access restrictions that could leave national security threats “remain invisible to investigators.” In his view, investigators face a difficult situation because they need access to the register precisely to prove that a violation occurred in the first place.
Mitchell also questioned the requirement obliging applicants to prove that all alternative sources have been pursued. According to him, the provision “entirely defeats the purpose of the register.” Jersey's consultation document does indeed require this, while Guernsey does not state it explicitly. He also highlighted potential access costs that could hinder openness, and stressed that such information should be free.
“Access must be open to parties from other jurisdictions, including those in the global south who have long been victims of the theft of global dirty money,” Mitchell said, urging that the proposal ultimately lead to a fully public register.
The governments of Guernsey and Jersey rejected the criticism. A spokesperson for the Government of Jersey said Mitchell's concerns “do not accurately reflect the content of the consultation paper” and stressed that the policy is designed to meet international commitments while maintaining a fair, proportionate, and effective transparency framework. Jersey claims it continues to meet international standards in combating money laundering, terrorist financing, and proliferation financing.
Similarly, Deputy Andrew Niles of Guernsey's Policy and Resources Committee rejected the notion that the proposal fails to meet commitments on beneficial ownership transparency. He pointed to a positive assessment in 2025 of the island's efforts to combat financial crime. Niles explained that the new framework will give access to parties acting in good faith investigating crime, while still protecting privacy and vulnerable individuals. “This proposal adopts a model that has been tested in the European Union,” he added.
Mitchell's criticism highlights a classic dilemma in financial transparency regimes: on one hand, offshore jurisdictions such as Guernsey and Jersey face international pressure to open ownership data; on the other, they seek to protect the financial services industry that is the backbone of their economies. For Indonesia, this development is relevant because corporate ownership transparency is a global issue that the country also faces in its efforts to prevent money laundering and terrorist financing. Indonesia itself already has a beneficial ownership policy, but implementation challenges and public access remain debated.
Looking ahead, will Guernsey and Jersey soften their access requirements to meet international demands, or hold to the model they consider balanced? The answer will determine how effective global efforts are in closing dark financial loopholes, and will also serve as a mirror for other countries—including Indonesia—in designing a truly open ownership register.



