European Pesticides Found to Poison 1,605 Brazilian Farmers, Including Brands Banned in the UK
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Sebanyak 1.605 laporan keracunan di Brasil tahun lalu melibatkan merek pestisida yang dipasarkan perusahaan kimia Eropa, menurut investigasi Unearthed dan Public Eye.
- Sekitar sepertiga bahan aktif dalam produk tersebut telah dilarang di Uni Eropa karena risiko kesehatan dan lingkungan, namun tetap diproduksi untuk ekspor.
- Reglone, Dormex, dan Roundup termasuk produk yang disebut dalam laporan, memicu pertanyaan tentang standar ganda dalam regulasi pestisida global.

A recent investigation revealed that 1,605 of 2,857 pesticide poisoning reports in Brazil last year named brand-name products sold by European chemical companies. The findings were reported by Unearthed and Public Eye after analyzing data from Brazil's Ministry of Health, and highlight the practice of exporting hazardous chemicals that have been banned in the European Union.
According to the report, about a third of the identified cases involved active ingredients that are not permitted for use on European farmland because of their impact on human health and the environment. However, European companies are still allowed to produce these substances for export to countries with looser regulations, including Brazil. The practice has drawn accusations of a "deadly double standard" from environmental activists.
The data show that of 6,700 medical reports related to agricultural pesticides, 2,857 named identifiable products. A total of 1,420 were classified as confirmed poisonings, while another 1,108 were classified as exposures. Most diagnoses were based on clinical assessment because laboratory confirmation was rarely performed. Experts noted that the lack of training among health workers was a major obstacle to confirming cases.
Reglone, a herbicide whose active ingredient is diquat and which is manufactured by Syngenta at its Huddersfield plant in the UK, was among the most frequently named products. Diquat has been banned for use in the UK since 2020 because of the high risk to workers and nearby communities. Nevertheless, production for export continues. The tragic story of Nelson Castoldi, a farmer from Rio Grande do Sul, is clear evidence: he died after accidentally swallowing Reglone that had been stored in a used cola bottle. His family said they were devastated, and four months later his wife died of depression and a stroke.
"That poison, Reglone, should be banned in Brazil. Not because of what happened to us, but because of its toxicity," said Ivan Castoldi, the victim's son.
Besides Reglone, Dormex (active ingredient cyanamide), produced by Germany's Alzchem and distributed by BASF, also caused victims. Sidnei Souza de Oliveira (49) suffered severe injuries after Dormex liquid spilled on his leg. His skin turned black and his flesh rotted, requiring surgery. He said he was afraid of losing his job if he was absent too long. Cyanamide has been banned in the EU since 2008 because of the health risk to farmers.
Finale (glufosinate) and Roundup (glyphosate) were also recorded in the reports. Glufosinate is classified as a reproductive toxicant in the EU, while Roundup was named in 12 deaths. The companies disputed the findings. Syngenta said nearly half of the cases linked to its products were not confirmed as poisonings, and accused the investigation of ignoring the final classification of the dataset. Bayer questioned the reliability of the data and said "Roundup" is often used as a generic term for other herbicides. BASF expressed concern and stressed that some incidents may have involved deliberate consumption as "intentional misuse".
Greenpeace UK called on the UK to stop exporting pesticides that are banned domestically. "If a pesticide is too dangerous to be used in the UK, then it is too dangerous to be exported," said Nina Schrank, senior campaigner at Greenpeace UK. She urged ministers not to let the UK be part of a production chain for toxic chemicals that endanger lives abroad.
The issue is also relevant to Indonesia, a major importer of agricultural products and chemicals. Although the report contains no direct data on Indonesia, similar practices can occur in developing countries with looser regulations. Indonesia needs to tighten oversight of pesticides that have been banned in their countries of origin, and improve training for farmers and health workers in recognizing poisoning symptoms. Data transparency and stronger notification systems are key to preventing similar victims.
Going forward, pressure on European chemical companies to stop exporting hazardous pesticides is expected to increase. Existing EU regulations do not cover production for the export market, so this gap continues to be exploited. The question is whether Brazil and other countries will tighten marketing permits, or instead become dumping grounds for products no longer accepted in developed countries?



