London Youth Employment Scheme Deemed a Failure: Only 42% of Participants Land Jobs or Education
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Dari 2.600 anak muda London yang dibantu program senilai £20 juta, hanya 1.100 yang berhasil lanjut ke pendidikan, pelatihan, atau kerja.
- Pemerintah Inggris membela program sebagai upaya menjangkau kelompok paling terpinggirkan, sementara kritikus menuntut insentif langsung bagi dunia usaha.
- Laporan besar dari mantan menteri Alan Milburn pekan depan diperkirakan menawarkan solusi baru untuk hampir satu juta anak muda Inggris yang tidak bekerja, sekolah, atau pelatihan.

Only 1,100 of the 2,600 young Londoners who received support from the £20 million Youth Guarantee Trailblazer program moved into further education, employment, or training. That means fewer than half of participants actually progressed in the expected direction, according to first-year data released by the Greater London Authority (GLA) to the BBC.
The centrally funded program targets 16–24-year-olds classified as Neet—not in employment, education, or training. London is one of eight regions in England testing the scheme, with total national funding of £90 million over two years through March 2027. But the capital's results have sparked a political debate: whether that much public money has hit the target or was misdesigned from the start.
Conservative peer Shaun Bailey, a former social worker now sitting in the House of Lords, called the results a failure. According to him, the share of participants who did not move into full-time work or education—around 60%—shows the scheme is not working effectively. He argued the money should instead be redirected to ease burdens on companies so they can create jobs for young people, rather than expanding training programs that ultimately do not lead to job placements.
Skills Minister Jacqui Smith strongly rejected that assessment. She stressed the program was designed to reach young people furthest from the labor market, including those grappling with mental health issues or with experience of the care system. Smith described the many participants who succeeded on their first attempt as a positive outcome, and said the scheme is working within the parameters set from the outset. She added that the program is still in its early stages and that learning about how to engage vulnerable groups is ongoing.
Behind the numbers, individual stories show how complicated the problem is. Mattie Davies, 19, graduated from college and immediately hit a wall of rejection. He said he applied for thousands of vacancies, but the responses were almost always negative. He now works as a delivery driver, though his pay is not enough to cover his bills. Davies did not receive help from the trailblazer scheme; he was supported instead by a community program run by Millwall FC, the football club where he plays. For him, the job he wants is not just anything that accepts his application, but a chance to build himself up and break down barriers.
The failure to absorb more than half of participants highlights a classic gap in labor market programs: training and mentoring do not automatically lead to decent work. In London, the high cost of living means low-paid work such as freelance driving is not enough to be self-sufficient. Programs focused on mental health, mentoring, and work experience are important, but without real demand from businesses, results can stop at the training room. The UK government itself faces fiscal pressure, making the effectiveness of public spending a sharp focus.
Next week, a major report from former minister Alan Milburn is expected to offer a new roadmap for tackling the Neet problem, which affects nearly one million people across England. Milburn's recommendations could be a test for the government: whether to expand similar schemes, change incentives for companies, or combine both. What is clear is that with the March 2027 funding deadline, decisions on policy direction can no longer be postponed. The question now is whether London and other regions will learn from this 42% figure—or repeat the same model under a different name.



