Shayne Pattynama Sidelined at Persija: The Mystery of the National Team Defender's Absence in the Shin Tae-yong Era
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Shayne Pattynama belum sekalipun tampil untuk Persija di BRI Super League 2026/2027, bahkan tak pernah masuk daftar susunan pemain dalam delapan laga.
- Keputusan Shin Tae-yong memprioritaskan Pratama Arhan dan Dony Tri Pamungkas di sektor kiri pertahanan memunculkan tanda tanya mengingat rekam jejak Shayne di level internasional.
- Persija akan menjamu Persebaya di JIS pada laga pekan kesembilan, menjadi ujian apakah Shayne akhirnya diberi kesempatan atau penantiannya berlanjut.

Shayne Pattynama has yet to experience the atmosphere of an official match with Persija Jakarta this season. Since Shin Tae-yong took the helm at Macan Kemayoran, the Indonesia national team left-back has not received a single minute of playing time in the BRI Super League 2026/2027. In fact, across eight league matches, his name has never appeared on the team sheet. This situation contrasts with his important role at national level and raises questions about the direction of the South Korean coach's policy.
Shayne joined Persija in the second round of last season and recorded ten appearances under Mauricio Souza. However, the arrival of Shin Tae-yong brought major change. The coach who led Indonesia to the final of the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 prefers Pratama Arhan and Dony Tri Pamungkas for the left-back position. Arhan is always the first choice, while Dony often comes on as a substitute.
In the I.League Cup 2026/2027 match against PSMS Medan on Tuesday (3/11/2026), Shayne finally made the team sheet. Hope for a debut emerged. Yet Shin Tae-yong still started Arhan and played him the full 90 minutes, while Dony came on in the 67th minute. Shayne could only watch his teammates play from the bench. After the match, he was seen training alone on the pitch, fueling speculation about his condition and future at the club.
Shin Tae-yong's decision not to play Shayne has drawn scrutiny because the 28-year-old is not without experience. He has played in the Netherlands, Norway, and Belgium before continuing in Thailand and Indonesia. At international level, Shayne was trusted to take a penalty in the final of the ASEAN Cup 2026, showing his mental and technical quality. It is this contrast between his role in the national team and his situation at the club that has led Indonesian football fans to question the reasons behind Shin Tae-yong's rotation policy.
"Shayne is not just any player. He has proven his ability at international level. The lack of opportunities at the club is certainly a big question mark," said a national football observer, as quoted from a social media discussion.
Competition on the left flank is indeed tight. Pratama Arhan and Dony Tri Pamungkas are the two names who earned Shin Tae-yong's trust first. Arhan is known for his distinctive long throw and aggression in defense, while Dony offers energy and pace. However, Shayne's considerable quality has led many to suspect non-technical factors, such as long-term strategy or fitness condition, that have not been disclosed to the public. Bola.com has tried to contact Shayne's side, but there has been no response.
From the team management's perspective, Shin Tae-yong's decision could be part of an effort to build squad depth. With a packed schedule in the league and cup competitions, player rotation is inevitable. However, completely overlooking a player of Shayne's caliber across eight league matches certainly raises questions about the effectiveness of squad management. If left unchecked, this situation could lower the player's market value and affect Shayne's confidence, which would also impact the Indonesia national team's performance in upcoming events.
Persija itself faces a stern test by hosting Persebaya Surabaya at Jakarta International Stadium this Saturday night. This classic fixture always draws attention and is a chance for Shin Tae-yong to show whether Shayne Pattynama will finally be given an opportunity or instead be pushed further to the margins. The public waits to see whether the coach's decision will change, or whether Shayne's wait will continue throughout the season.



