Problems of Compensation for Damage in Criminal Proceedings: Legal Aspects and Development Prospects

This article examines the challenges of compensating damage in criminal proceedings in Kazakhstan, highlighting gaps in legal regulation and the need for reforms aligned with international human rights standards.

T. A. Khanov· Теория и практика общественного развития· 2025· DOI 10.24158/tipor.2025.2.23

The core problem

The article addresses the complex issues surrounding compensation for damage in the criminal process of the Republic of Kazakhstan. It emphasizes the importance of legal regulation and the necessity of effective compensation mechanisms to protect the rights and interests of citizens. The author highlights the limitations of existing approaches to the interaction between law enforcement agencies and citizens, particularly during pre-trial investigation, where the actions of law enforcement agencies can lead to violations of individual rights. The need to adjust national legislation in the field of compensation for damage caused by both illegal and legal actions in criminal proceedings is underscored. The author also stresses the importance of creating an effective system for compensating violations of constitutional rights of participants in legal proceedings and adopting legislative acts that comply with international standards for the protection of human rights.

The article employs a legal analysis approach, examining the existing legal framework and practices in Kazakhstan regarding compensation for damage in criminal proceedings. It reviews national legislation, international standards, and scholarly perspectives to identify gaps and propose reforms. The methodology includes a critical assessment of the interaction between law enforcement agencies and citizens, with a focus on pre-trial investigation phases. The author draws on comparative legal analysis to highlight discrepancies between national practices and international human rights standards, and calls for an interdisciplinary approach to studying compensation issues.

Introduction

The article addresses the complex issues surrounding compensation for damage in the criminal process of the Republic of Kazakhstan. It emphasizes the importance of legal regulation and the necessity of effective compensation mechanisms to protect the rights and interests of citizens. The author highlights the limitations of existing approaches to the interaction between law enforcement agencies and citizens, particularly during pre-trial investigation, where the actions of law enforcement agencies can lead to violations of individual rights. The need to adjust national legislation in the field of compensation for damage caused by both illegal and legal actions in criminal proceedings is underscored. The author also stresses the importance of creating an effective system for compensating violations of constitutional rights of participants in legal proceedings and adopting legislative acts that comply with international standards for the protection of human rights.

The discussion centers on the need for a paradigm shift in how compensation for damage in criminal proceedings is approached. The author argues that current legal frameworks are insufficient to protect citizens' rights and that reforms must be guided by international human rights standards. The importance of an interdisciplinary approach is emphasized, integrating legal, sociological, and criminological perspectives to develop new methodologies. The author calls for increased accountability of law enforcement agencies and the adoption of legislative acts that ensure effective compensation for violations. The article concludes by highlighting the pressing need for comprehensive research and the development of new methodologies to address this issue, ultimately aiming to harmonize national legislation with international norms and enhance the protection of individual rights in criminal proceedings.

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…