The Fed Is About to Hike Into Falling Prices, and the Market Is Crying Foul
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Federal Reserve officials are pushing for further rate hikes based on October CPI and PPI data, even as gasoline and commodity prices have fallen sharply in recent weeks.
- The 3-2-1 crack spread has collapsed 36% in six weeks, and wholesale gasoline futures are down nearly 20% in three weeks, pointing to a sharp decline in inflation pressures that the Fed may be ignoring.
- If the Fed follows through with a 50-basis-point hike in December, risk assets including bitcoin could face a fresh headwind, while critics warn the central bank is hiking into a supply glut that is already doing its job.

Federal Reserve officials are preparing to raise interest rates again, but the data they are relying on may already be obsolete. The central bank’s October meeting minutes, released Wednesday, showed that nearly all participants believed further tightening would be necessary to bring inflation back to the 2% target. Yet analysts point out that the inflation reports driving this stance—the consumer price index (CPI) and producer price index (PPI)—reflect price pressures from October, before a sharp drop in energy and commodity prices took hold.
The disconnect is stark. While CPI and PPI showed inflation broadening across goods and services last month, live market indicators such as gasoline futures, pump prices, and the crack spread—the profit margin refiners earn from turning crude into fuel—are signaling that inflationary pressures are already fading. The 3-2-1 crack spread, a key gauge of refining profitability, has plunged 36% in six weeks, from $65.56 a barrel to $41.90, according to data shared by James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at Wellington Altus. That collapse suggests fuel prices are falling faster than crude, which typically precedes a drop in retail pump prices.
“Inflation is a lagging indicator. It tells you what you paid last month. The crack spread is a leading indicator. It tells you what you’ll pay next month,” said Thierry Borgeat, co-founder and chief investment officer of Arvy, a Zurich-based asset manager regulated by FINMA. “The Fed is listening to the first one. It’s about to hike into falling prices at the pump.”
The drop extends beyond gasoline. Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Investment Research, tracked commodity exchange-traded funds as of Wednesday’s close. The gasoline fund (UGA) is down 20.9% month-to-date, the US crude oil fund (USO) 19.4%, and the Brent crude fund (BNO) 18.7%. Broad commodity funds are off about 12%, with copper (CPER) down 12.5%, wheat (WEAT) 4.6%, corn (CORN) 2.7%, and gold (GLD) 4.1%. Natural gas (UNG) is the exception, up 16.9% this month.
Despite these signals, several Fed officials have publicly advocated for a larger hike. Governor Christopher Waller told CNBC on Wednesday that he supports a 50-basis-point increase in December, double the usual quarter-point step. Governor Michael Barr said higher rates would likely be appropriate, and San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly called for a measured approach. Interest-rate futures are currently pricing in quarter-point hikes in December and January, with another by April.
“Collapsing margins also mean more relief is coming. Retail prices lag wholesale by weeks, so the pump hasn’t finished falling. Every 10 cents off gasoline takes about 9 basis points off headline CPI. November is shaping up for a negative headline print, and in March the war spike drops out of the year-over-year math. This is a supply glut, not a demand problem, and it’s doing the Fed’s job for it. Hiking 1% into a collapsing refining margin isn’t vigilance. It’s insanity.” — James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at Wellington Altus
Some market participants see a deeper motive behind the Fed’s hawkish rhetoric. “At this point, with multiple Fed officials calling for a 50-basis-point hike in December, despite clear easing of energy pressure on prices, I can only believe that the Fed is trying to crash the market verbally to give them cover to stop hiking altogether soon. Nothing else makes any sense,” said James Lavish, co-managing partner of Bitcoin Opportunity Fund.
For cryptocurrency investors, the prospect of further rate hikes is a familiar headwind. Higher borrowing costs tend to weigh on risk assets like bitcoin, which has already been under pressure from a broader market selloff. The Fed’s stance could exacerbate that trend if it follows through with aggressive tightening.
Beyond the immediate market impact, the debate raises questions about the reliability of backward-looking data in a rapidly changing economy. As Borgeat notes, the Fed risks repeating a classic central banking error: fighting the last war. With energy prices now in freefall and a supply glut in refined products, the case for pausing rate hikes is growing—even as officials insist otherwise.
Investors will be watching incoming inflation data and Fed communications closely in the coming weeks. If November CPI comes in negative, as Thorne predicts, the Fed may find itself hiking into a disinflationary trend, undermining its credibility and potentially triggering a sharp reversal in risk assets. For now, the market is left to wonder: will the Fed blink before it’s too late?



